Skip to content
Scope123

Mercer Super ordered to pay $11.3m in ASIC greenwashing case

The Federal Court ordered Mercer Superannuation to pay $11.3 million on 2 August 2024 over misleading claims about seven Sustainable Plus investment options.

Standards & regulationScope123 News Desk

Super trustees and fund managers publishing sustainability claims about investment options now have a court penalty to measure against. On 2 August 2024 the Federal Court ordered Mercer Superannuation (Australia) Limited to pay $11.3 million, in what ASIC's media release 24-173MR describes as its first greenwashing case before the Federal Court.

Mercer admitted it made misleading statements about the sustainable nature and characteristics of seven "Sustainable Plus" investment options in the Mercer Super Trust, of which it is trustee.

What the website said and what members held

Mercer's website said the options suited members deeply committed to sustainability, and that they excluded companies involved in carbon-intensive fossil fuels such as thermal coal, alcohol production and gambling. Members' investments in fact included:

  • 15 companies involved in extracting or selling carbon-intensive fossil fuels, including AGL Energy, BHP Group, Glencore and Whitehaven Coal
  • 15 alcohol producers, including Carlsberg, Heineken Holding and Treasury Wine Estates
  • 19 gambling companies, including Aristocrat Leisure, Crown Resorts and Tabcorp

Justice Horan found the contraventions arose from Mercer's failure to put in place adequate systems to check its ESG claims were accurate and to monitor and enforce the exclusions. He described them as serious. Mercer agreed to pay ASIC's costs.

What it means for anyone making ESG claims

The court's finding was about systems: the exclusions were stated publicly but not monitored against the actual holdings. If your organisation publishes exclusion or sustainability claims about a product, check that someone tests them against the portfolio and keeps a record of the result.

ASIC's later greenwashing penalties against Vanguard and Active Super followed.

More from Standards & regulation