Skip to content
Scope123

Vanguard ordered to pay $12.9m over ESG screening claims

The Federal Court ordered Vanguard Investments Australia to pay $12.9 million on 25 September 2024 over false ESG screening claims for an ethical bond fund.

Standards & regulationScope123 News Desk

Fund managers that describe ESG screens in disclosure documents now have a second Federal Court greenwashing penalty to measure against. On 25 September 2024 Justice O'Bryan ordered Vanguard Investments Australia Ltd to pay $12.9 million, which ASIC's media release 24-213MR calls the highest greenwashing penalty to date.

The case concerned the Vanguard Ethically Conscious Global Aggregate Bond Index Fund (Hedged). On 28 March 2024 the court declared that Vanguard had made false or misleading statements about the fund in 12 product disclosure statements, a media release, its website, a YouTube interview and a fund manager presentation.

What the court found

Vanguard represented that securities in the fund's index were researched and screened against ESG criteria, and that securities breaching those criteria were excluded. Only companies, and generally only listed companies, were screened. About 74% of the fund's securities by market value were not researched or screened against the criteria. The court's penalty orders record that the index included 39 issuers breaching the criteria, including on fossil fuels and alcohol, and the fund included 12.

How the penalty was set

ASIC sought $21.6 million. Vanguard argued for $9 million to $11.25 million. The court applied a 25% discount for Vanguard's cooperation in ASIC's investigation and in the proceeding. Vanguard must publish an adverse publicity notice on four of its web pages for 12 months and pay ASIC's costs, apart from the costs of a hearing on 8 March 2024, which ASIC pays.

What it means for screened products

The screen covered companies, while the claims were made about the fund as a whole, which also held securities from issuers that were never screened. If your product disclosure describes a screen, check that it says which issuers and asset types the screen covers.

ASIC's first greenwashing penalty, against Mercer Super, came seven weeks earlier.

More from Standards & regulation